What Do You Think Is Overrated On BTVS/AtS?

I think using "Found Family" to describe some high school friends hanging out together while in their early twenties is an over extended reading of the concept.
Post automatically merged:

I'm willing to accept that criticism of Tara/Amber. "Once More with Feeling" is very much Dr. Johnson's proverbial dog walking on it's hind legs, it's not so much that it's done well, but that it done at all.
 
Last edited:
Much as the Angel-Buffy story-line doesn't do anything for me, partly due to the huge age difference, I think there's an argument for someone who is responsible for the salvation of the entire planet considering herself an adult and grabbing what love she can WHILE SHE'S STILL ALIVE.

I also dislike the relationship, but even if Buffy was not the Slayer, she is still old enough to, you know, die for her country. (And she is over the age of consent in most of the world.) "Hey, it is perfectly okay if you are killed. But have sex? No, that is wrong."

I find a lot of the age restrictions utterly ludicrous. The idea that you can be judged to be mature enough to make a literally life or death decision that will affect the rest of your life yet not mature enough to vote, drink, smoke or have sex is wrong. If you are old enough to join a country's military, you should be old enough to do anything.
 
I think Andrew is very overrated.

And I think the friendship between Tara and Buffy seems to be hyped up into something it really isn't. They had a bonding moment when Joyce died - because Buffy could now relate to Tara over the loss of a parent.
In s6 when she cried to her about the whole Spike saga - it's because Tara was on the outskirts and not really inside the inner Scooby circle. It's because of the fact they're not close Buffy can speak to her. It continues the pattern where Buffy couldn't actually talk to those closest to her (and she certainly couldn't talk to Willow about magic and spells).

And then Tara told Willow about them sleeping together, when Buffy asked her not to tell anyone. Doesn't matter if Willow suspected it, it wasn't Tara's place.
 
I would agree Buffy's relationship with Angel is overrated. I might agree Angel is overrated as a character if we were talking about Buffy only, but he really came into himself on the spin-off. I think tbh the importance of who Buffy is involved with can be overrated at times.

I know I'm coming in late on this one, but I'm pretty sure all the actors actually did sing their songs in Once More With Feeling including Amber Benson. I checked Wikipedia and a couple of other sources which all say this. Tara sings in a park of course, so Amber may have dubbed it, but I'm almost certain it was her singing.
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
Quite a few did have singing training, especially ASH.
1. Willow. I wanted Tara for myself.

No but seriously this girl could’ve gotten drunk and decided ‘meh I’m gonna end the world’

She had too much power and needed to be checked sooner!

And that ‘oh I’m so nerdy hehe, I just don’t know what I’m doing…’

Ugh it’s infuriating.

2. Angel - the show

Spinoff for this guy? I wanted a spin-off of Dru, or Spike.

The show Angel is like watching ghostbusters with a protagonist that can’t dance or keep a girlfriend.

His only successful relationship is with Spike. Any Spangel fans?

3. Buffy’s relationships

All of Buffy’s dark and broody girlfriends (Spike, Angel, Faith) were toxic and attractive.

I can’t even hate it’s too entertaining..
 
Last edited:
Surprise and Innocence are like the highest rated episodes of the series. Whatever Bangle was. It really appealed to Teenage girls in 1997.
 
Surprise and Innocence are good episodes: because they move away from Buffy and Angel as a couple and starts to make them into antagonists. Which is far more interesting.
Surprise is awful. Its melodramatic nonsense. Plus "Drusilla might still be alive, we never saw her body"
I guess Buffy forgets that Vampires turn to dust when they die 🤷‍♂️

Innocence is brilliant it turns lead into gold as an episode. Also the rain really helped because having Xander in a normal coat trying not to draw attention walking round a Military base works better than a very bright and loud Haiwan shirt that was Joss intention
Post automatically merged:

Bangel, no question. The relationship is at best, boring and tiresome, and at worst, toxic.*

*take my opinion with a grain of salt though, I am biased

I agree. I think it was fine for the Angelus arc in Season 2 but after that it was boring especially in S3 which was rinse and repeat over and over. So much so even the writers made fun of it
 
The main value of Oz was actually showcasing a healthy and non-toxic relationship, which are few and far between on Buffy.
 
I found Adam and the Initiative to be a rather painful slog. I didn't loathe Riley, but they weren't my favourites by any means. The military thing I was happy to see gone for good.
 
Back
Top Bottom