Twilight

nightshade

Your grandfather is a cat
Staff member
Joined
Mar 13, 2009
Messages
18,450
Location
England
Black Thorn
Since a few of us have reading/discussing the books, I thought that we could have a thread for it. I'd like to keep it positive but I don't like the films!

My issues with the film are mostly in the casting, Charlie is not my Charlie and the Cullens are no where near pretty enough, plus the weird hair.

Also I don't like how much got changed from the books.

Now back to the books, they are just a comfort read, like a cup of tea in a book. There's nothing too graphic or gory in it, it's quite old fashioned in that way.

Alice is my favourite character, I'd happily read a book about her, and I love the closeness of her and Edward, and then later, Bella and Charlie.

Took me a while to warm up to Rosalie, but her background is great, and how she found Emmett.
 
Puppet
Puppet
Omg, Charlie is exactly the same from book to movie, he's the only good part from the film!!!
Nix
Nix
Do they still sparkle in the books?
I have not read the books. I watched part of the first film and it completely put me off the franchise. Now I am wondering whether I should give the books a chance!
Do, the books are so much better. The first film irritates me with its changes as well, the books explain everything so much better.
 
I've only read the first book, and only seen part of the first film.

The book had some nice descriptive parts of the Pacific northwest, and my being in such areas helped my imagination. It looked so much better in my mind's eye than the strange coloring of the movie...I heard or read there was a reason the movie went with that color, but I can't recall it now.

One major difference is that Bella is more of a blank slate, and I was grudgingly impressed by that. She uses "my favorite search engine" and listens to her "favorite music." Which could be anything. Won't be dated anytime soon, avoids alienating some readers, and allows for maximum projection into the story. It's not my kind of story, but I was impressed with how well they did that without it interrupting the flow of the story. Naturally, it was impossible to do it to that extent in the movie.

Given how many years have gone by, I may be forgetting something, but I don't think the movie left out something really...awkward...the way many such movies based on such books do. Which I point out as if you can handle the movie, the book should not be a problem. The only parts I think they cut out (and again, I haven't seen the entire movie) could easily be seen as just due to time constraints rather than realizing how messed up one scene is that will get them a much more strict rating if they put it in the movie (so leave it out for that reason), such as with 50 Shades of Grey. If the movie doesn't bother you, then the book shouldn't either.
 
I still have a fondness for the first film, actually. The rest not so much. But the first I thought did a decent job of it. A bit cheesy perhaps.

As you know I'm not reading Midnight Sun, and will be for a while. I thought it was just the first Twilight from Edward's pov, but at 800 pages it's got to be almost the whole series?

Then I'm planning to go back to the beginning with the others. I do remember finding them very comforting the first time around (except Jakob forcing Bella to kiss him in number two or three. There's a beach scene I remember made me very uncomfortable, back then). Also, except Breaking Dawn. The only thing that I liked about Breaking Dawn was Bella running to Rosalie for help, and them bonding - not really but a bit - over her pregnancy and wanting to keep the baby. I rather like idea of Bella and Rosalie becoming more friendly, so it seemed long overdue.

I don't remember liking Alice all that much, but I think it is partly the film influencing me there.
 
nightshade
nightshade
Nope Midnight Sun is just the first book!
Skanky Vamp
Skanky Vamp
how long will it take you to not read the book?
I liked about Breaking Dawn was Bella running to Rosalie for help, and them bonding - not really but a bit - over her pregnancy and wanting to keep the baby. I rather like idea of Bella and Rosalie becoming more friendly, so it seemed long overdue.
Yes, I think the film skims over that a lot, but it's a great bonding time for them. The whole pregnancy is skimmed over, we don't get any of the Alice and Jacob moments in the film either.

I dislike Jacob, both book and film version, find him completely unnecessary except for early New Moon, when he was actually being a friend to Bella, but overall he's a bad friend.
 
Nope Midnight Sun is just the first book!

Wait, so Edward's brooding adds hundreds of pages to the original? Oh boy, I'm in for a treat. I started listening to it once, but gave up. Well, I'll try to stick with it this time. But maybe it was the wrong end to start with.
 
@Puppet don't laugh, but it's the mustache! My Charlie does not have a mustache! Also I think he's kinda old, Charlie is late 30s and film Charlie looks older than that. He could look younger without the mustache I'm sure!

@Taake it is a lot longer, yours longer than mine, mine is only 750 pages, but it is still only book one, ending at the prom.
 
I liked the first film too. It was so over the top, and I was heavily immersed in the fandom at the time, sucking up every snippet and enjoying the lolz. It was a fun time.

The others are very different in tone, more Hollywood, less indy. New moon is boring cos it was a boring book, and film cant capture the true nature of Bellas withdrawal from Edward. And RPattz was just not buff enough to sparkle in Italy. Might be better if they re-do that scene with the Batman bod 😉 I did like the way they captured the suspense in the film though.

Eclipse was perfect, all glitzy and glamourous and pretty and sexy. Needed more Jasper on horseback tho. Would have been cool if they had shown Alice and Jasper meeting, it would have been cute. And I wish I had never seen Jacob/Taylor in the green suit getting pet on the head. I cant watch that without cracking up laughing.

I still think Breaking Dawn the movie was better than the books. More action! They did have to change Alice and Jasper interactions because technically Alice couldn't see the wolves, but in the film she can. The pregnancy wouldn't have transferred well to screen either so Im glad it wasnt dragged out.

I agree @Puppet movie Charlie is great! Waaaay hotter than i imagined 😆
 
@Puppet don't laugh, but it's the mustache! My Charlie does not have a mustache! Also I think he's kinda old, Charlie is late 30s and film Charlie looks older than that. He could look younger without the mustache I'm sure!
I know, that was on purpose! Billy Burke wasn't old enough to pass for a father of a 17-year-old, so he grew the affectionately named porn-stache 🙂

Also, how dare you call him old, Billy Burke is a handsome devil and nowhere near as old as Charlie!!! :O
 
nightshade
nightshade
It's clearly the mustache, very off putting!
Oh my eyes just skipped over any objections to movie-Charlie, lol, I read Carlisle and nodded along. I don't hate movie Carlisle to be clear, he just looks a bit creepy and not necessarily in a good way. Movie Charlie is hot, I will agree with that choir, love Billy Burke as Charlie. He breaks my heart every time when Bella leaves with his sad little face!
 
nightshade
nightshade
Oh Carlisle is very odd looking, but i object to all the casting of the Cullens
I know, that was on purpose! Billy Burke wasn't old enough to pass for a father of a 17-year-old, so he grew the affectionately named porn-stache 🙂

Also, how dare you call him old, Billy Burke is a handsome devil and nowhere near as old as Charlie!!! :O
Oh I looked him up, much better looking without that mustache.

My main issue with the first film is the vampire reveal part. It makes Bella seem afraid in the woods, whereas in the book, it's a calm discussion in the car.
 
Yeah, the book is far superior to the film, even if neither is all that great to begin with. Every time I watch Twilight I just find myself going 'they did this way better in the book'. Like the meadow scene where Edward starts violently showing how powerful he is? In the book he's all soft and quiet as he explains it, so why change it so drastically? 😵
 
Taake
Taake
better visuals I guess
My pet peeve from the movie vs the book is the scene when Bella is in the car after being very cold and talks about Jacob being like his own sun. Its all sweet and innocent in the book and Kstew acts it out like SkankyMcSkankface. No wonder the poor kid gets confused!
 
Everything is calmer in the books, and more action, and intense in the films. It gives a different feel to the story.
 
Yeah, the book is far superior to the film, even if neither is all that great to begin with. Every time I watch Twilight I just find myself going 'they did this way better in the book'. Like the meadow scene where Edward starts violently showing how powerful he is? In the book he's all soft and quiet as he explains it, so why change it so drastically? 😵

It's like The Craft, Rochelle's original storyline was that she had a severe eating disorder. Then they changed it to her being bullied by racist characters which is much more "hands on" and easy to portray in the movie.

I've seen the actress talk about how that bothered her because it made her character all about her race, and I agree with that, or I at least think that they should've kept both storylines. Because I understand the problem of how do they show her ED getting solved by magic? Doesn't make for very interesting visuals, as compared to your bully's hair falling out. (This has bothered me since I learned it, because I would've loved for them to flesh out both Rochelle and Bonnie more)

Same with Edward, people expect action in a vampire movie. Them talking in a car is "boring". At least for the kind of movie they wanted to make.
Conversely, him showing off + the woods is rather cartoonish instead, so I would've prefered a calmer version too.
 
I think getting Edward right was always going to be difficult, with the mind reading, there's a lot he hears instead of others speaking.

I'm interested in if they will make the tv series and how faithful that will be to the books.
 
Taake
Taake
A tv-series - would team Bella/Alice put the smack down on teams Jacob and Edward maybe?
I rekon RPattz did a fabulous job in the first movie. He clearly took the acting part of it very seriously, even if he didn't take the source material seriously.

The looks when he was reading minds were perfect (with Carlisle at the hospital and at the first body). If they do a tv series, something like that would certainly work. It'd be easy to add in whispers as the thoughts.

One of my favourite scenes was the restaurant scene. It felt true to the books, I could feel the atmosphere when I read it and when I watched it. Its hard to know if those sorts of things worked as well for people who had only seen the movie without first reading the book.
 
It'd be easy to add in whispers as the thoughts.
I think that would be good, so we get both sides of the conversation.

Maybe the tv series could incorporate bits from Midnight Sun as well, as that wasn't out when the films were made.
 
Back
Top Bottom