The Replacement: If you were Anya or Xander, would you?

[NotASlayer]

When Xander is split in two in The Replacement, Anya had a very... let's go with practical use for the Xanders. And the Xanders did seem... tempted.

So, if you, or your partner was split in two, would you go with Anya's idea? Would you do it if your partner was split in two? Or would you do it if you were the one split in two and your partner suggested it? Does one appeal more than the other? Or does neither appeal.

 

[AlphaFoxtrot]

Anya is a well known degenerate, Xander has been entertaining her interests for quite some time, and occasionally, the writers want us to believe he has homosexual inclinations. Also, both are like 19/27. I would say no, but I'm 45 and increasingly find myself thinking all sex is gross.

 

[wolfheart]

I am one kind of woman, two is to crowded

 

[DeepBlueJoy]

come on, if you like your partner... isn't two fun... especially if it's temporary? I think long term it would be a bit... much... all the irritations as well as all the nice stuff... though in this case, one is confident and the other is a dweeb so... maybe two is too many... good thing we don't actually have to decide things like this!! gigglesnort.

 

[SavvyScoobie]

Hell no. Way too overstimulating

 

[Kendar]

I mean, if you are the one split anything you do with "other you" is arguably masturbation.

 

[whatdBuffyDo]

I mean, how many times would you get to experience such a weird thing, I'd say go for it both as Anya and Xander lol

 

[Joan the Vampire Slayer]

Giddy Up I say...

 

[November]

Pass round the magic rod and turn it into a real party.

 

[hoponlilmama]

come on, if you like your partner... isn't two fun... especially if it's temporary? I think long term it would be a bit... much... all the irritations as well as all the nice stuff... though in this case, one is confident and the other is a dweeb so... maybe two is too many... good thing we don't actually have to decide things like this!! gigglesnort.

This is the answer - if it's a one-off then I guess....why not?
What are your thoughts, @NotASlayer ? What would you do?

 

[NotASlayer]

@hoponlilmama I get the appeal. After all, three is not necessarily a crowd*, it can be fun. 😀😉😳 And if you have enough feelings/attraction to someone in the first place, why not two of that someone? 😀

The twin threesome fantasy is a pretty common one (sometimes I wonder if the reason Anya gets stick about things like this is because she's not a man) and in this case you get rid of the issue of two related people, because they're both the same person. And just because you have two Xanders doesn't mean they have to have selfcest with each other. In such situations it's perfectly possible for two of the people to focus all of their... let's say attention on the third...

*Not going to comment on what a crowd can be...

 

[hoponlilmama]

@hoponlilmama I get the appeal. After all, three is not necessarily a crowd*, it can be fun. 😀😉😳 And if you have enough feelings/attraction to someone in the first place, why not two of that someone? 😀

The twin threesome fantasy is a pretty common one (sometimes I wonder if the reason Anya gets stick about things like this is because she's not a man) and in this case you get rid of the issue of two related people, because they're both the same person. And just because you have two Xanders doesn't mean they have to have selfcest with each other. In such situations it's perfectly possible for two of the people to focus all of their... let's say attention on the third...

*Not going to comment on what a crowd can be...

Ooh, Anya would dig the attention of two Xanders, that is certain! I mean, it's the person you are fond of, and it's now double the fondness. Wink wink, nudge nudge.

Not exactly the same, but I'm reminded of a Spillow fic I read where there was Sunnydale Spike, and AU (alternate universe) Spike - that was an entertaining read. 😄

 

[hoponlilmama]

@NotASlayer - If I ever come across Wanya fic and with that specific storyline, I'll keep it in mind and point you towards it!

 

[NotASlayer]

@NotASlayer - If I ever come across Wanya fic and with that specific storyline, I'll keep it in mind and point you towards it!

There isn't a whole lot around which means it's mostly erotica... 😀 There's an, um, interesting series on AO3 which starts off with Willow and Anya, then gets Buffy involved and winds up with an... unusual way of activating Potentials...