CWDP - How Accurate were Holden Webster's Analyses of Buffy?

NoShip

Scooby
Joined
Feb 12, 2023
Messages
1,335
Age
56
I think most of Holden's analyses were purposely wrong. Designed to activate Buffy's innate shame and low self-esteem.

Throughout S1 thru S7 CWDP, when is Buffy shown to feel superior to her family and friends? In The Yoko Factor when she calls them out on not being helpful? In Revelations when she pushes back at Xander's accusations? Throughout S6 when she hides her boinking Spike? In Becoming when she flees Sunnydale after sending Angel to Hell? Or in Anne when she doesn't contact anyone for months?

Personally, I think Webbs' connection to an all encompasing evil gave him the knowledge and motivation to mostly mess with Buffy through his "Psych 101" tricks.

Thoughts?
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
here is a thought for that Holden Webster, when was Buffy shown to feel superior to her dad?
I think there's some merit to Holden's diagnosis, even if it's not completely true. If there wasn't, it likely wouldn't have affected her the way that it did.

I would argue that Buffy does think she's superior, in the same way that someone like Batman does. She knows she has skills and abilities that make her superior, which puts her in a position to take charge of situations and make decisions for others, which I think makes her worry in her less secure moments that this isolation does make her see herself as better than her friends, which she feels guilty about. And sometimes this can be misread on the outside as arrogance, and sometimes it can actually manifest itself as arrogance (for instance, her desire to go back at Caleb with no new plan after what happened to the Potentials, to Xander.)
 
Pretty much everyone is superior to others in some ways, and inferior in other ways. And I think most folk realize that.

Buffy is superior at fighting and she knows it and can sometimes be arrogant about her fighting abilities. And she knows she's pretty, though I think is less arrogant about that. But she knows her flaws. She's not as brainy as say Willow, she has trouble connecting to people. On the whole, considering everything she's been through, I'd say Buffy is fairly mentally balanced.
 
my brain hurts about this question, who is holden? not to mock you NoShip

In the season seven episode "Conversations with Dead People," each cast member ostensibly has a conversation with a dead person who, in some way, tests their mettle, attempting to manipulate their weaknesses for the benefit of the First Evil ("Joyce," "Tara," "Cassie Newton" from "Help.") Buffy encounters newly risen vampire Holden Webb (Jonathan Woodward, who also portrayed Tracy on Firefly's "The Message" and Knox on Angel season five), a psychology student who recognizes Buffy. In breaks from fighting, Holden attempts to psychoanalyze her, suggesting she has a superiority complex and an inferiority complex about it.

Hope that helps a bit.
 
Last edited:
wolfheart
wolfheart
I digged in my memories about buffy episodes but cant remember it, gladly i have all the episodes so i gonna watch it soon.
I think most of Holden's analyses were purposely wrong. Designed to activate Buffy's innate shame and low self-esteem.

Throughout S1 thru S7 CWDP, when is Buffy shown to feel superior to her family and friends? In The Yoko Factor when she calls them out on not being helpful? In Revelations when she pushes back at Xander's accusations? Throughout S6 when she hides her boinking Spike? In Becoming when she flees Sunnydale after sending Angel to Hell? Or in Anne when she doesn't contact anyone for months?

Personally, I think Webbs' connection to an all encompasing evil gave him the knowledge and motivation to mostly mess with Buffy through his "Psych 101" tricks.

Thoughts?
Basically the show does a bad job differentiating between feeling superior and being superior. There is a reason even with her friends helping her, Buffy is constantly the one who puts her body on the line in a way they aren't
 
N
NoShip
True.
Not accurate. It was The First's gaslighting. Like all gaslighting, there are shards of truth to make Buffy feel bad

Was it the First though? The First had never shown an ability to possess people, even vampires, so it certainly seemed like Holden was the one doing the talking. Not saying it wasn't gaslighting, but every time the First was seen, they were doing it as a projection of a dead person (deadogram?). Holden was real.
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
It seems as though someone is not aware of the process of how a human becomes a vampire. The lore states that when a vampire kills a human the demon in the vampire eats/ sucks out the soul thereby killing the human!
Was it the First though? The First had never shown an ability to possess people, even vampires, so it certainly seemed like Holden was the one doing the talking. Not saying it wasn't gaslighting, but every time the First was seen, they were doing it as a projection of a dead person (deadogram?). Holden was real.

It's possible that the First gave Holden the information by appearing to him (as she did to Spike, Caleb, and others.) I haven't watched the episode in years, but I don't recall any specific indications of that. It could have been, and I could be failing to remember something, but I just remember it being the fact that Holden knew Buffy when he was alive (though she hardly noticed him) and he was applying what he knew from psychology class to what he knew of her. As I recall, he was surprised to find out that the Slayer was Buffy, wasn't he?
 
Holden is dead and a vampire. At one point he comments about how he feels connected to an all encompasing evil that is going to drag the world into a fiery hell. So he isn't close to being a disinterested therapist trying his best to help his patient. He has an agenda. He wants to impress his new evil pals (even if he hasn't met them yet). He has a skillset that he makes very good use of.
So Holden is advancing The First's agenda even if he doesn't know the plan. Not at all good for Buffy.

Just a thought, when Holden's "therapy session" ended, was Buffy better off, or, worse?
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
To answer that one must first learn how to recognize the different spelling between steak and stake.
.. every time the First was seen, they were doing it as a projection of a dead person (deadogram?). Holden was real.

Western Tomb-ion? Okay, that was terrible. 😛

Holden is dead and a vampire. At one point he comments about how he feels connected to an all encompasing evil that is going to drag the world into a fiery hell. So he isn't close to being a disinterested therapist trying his best to help his patient. He has an agenda. He wants to impress his new evil pals (even if he hasn't met them yet). He has a skillset that he makes very good use of.
So Holden is advancing The First's agenda even if he doesn't know the plan. Not at all good for Buffy.

I certainly wasn't suggesting he was a disinterested therapist or that he was trying to help. I was just suggesting that he was acting of his own accord, not as a puppet of the First Evil. If I recall correctly, he was surprised to find out that Buffy was the Slayer, which would indicate the First hasn't actually been speaking to him.

I had forgotten about his comment about feeling connected to something, but being a demon (a demon's essence puppeteering a human corpse), it would make sense that he could, well, sense such a powerful evil (especially given the First is directly created by and empowered by evil, which vampires would be a part of.) He was serving the First's agenda, but not, in my opinion, because he actually directly knew about or had contact with the First.

That said, maybe it's controversial, but not all vampires seem to have been created equally evil. Spike (whose evil changes depending on the company he keeps), Glasses Guy (from Spike's gang in "What's My Line?"), the boys Dawn goes out with in "All In," etc. Holden, for instance, doesn't seem motivated to do evil because it's evil, because he wants to harm people, but rather because he "should." He just seems to have accepted that he is a vampire and vampires do bad things. He even seems to regret having to fight Buffy, whom he seems to have liked in life. That's not evil in the active sense. And I don't think he was pretending because we have no evidence to suggest that he was. He maintains the same persona the entire time, right up until his death (unlike, say, Darla, whose sweet facade drops and reveals the real her when she takes her victims.)

Now, to be clear, this is not me saying these vampires were good. I'm simply pointing out that some vampires seem to be more amoral than immoral and some seem to be immoral but not actively evil in the sense of desiring evil for evil's sake. Just thinking aloud. Nobody tar and feather me. 😛
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
Isn't that removing the fun from a vampire who is good at being bad, not wishing them to tar and feather you. What's the difference twixt good or evil vampires? Hot or cold runny tar!
Was it the First though? The First had never shown an ability to possess people, even vampires, so it certainly seemed like Holden was the one doing the talking. Not saying it wasn't gaslighting, but every time the First was seen, they were doing it as a projection of a dead person (deadogram?). Holden was real.
It influenced lots. Every time something or someone said 'from beneath you it devours'
 
He was definitely trying to flare up Buffy's insecurities about why her different relationships had failed. Just like most people, deep down Buffy had probably wondered if it was her fault that they didn't work out.

As far as Holden claiming that she thought the guys she got with weren't worth it, I think that part was wrong. She clearly respected all of them to an extent, even Spike with whom it was quite complicated.

Concerning her superiority complex, it's not that surprising. She had been forced into a role where she had to make major, difficult decisions. That she'd feel like she knows better than others sometimes sounded pretty natural to me.

One thing Holden mentioned that I thought was right on the money was how Buffy had trouble opening up to others.
 
About Buffy's superiority complex, Buffy was fashioned as a Vampire Slayer by the Powers That Be, the goody good two shoes of the universe. So is it not surprising that Buffy grew to create herself a superiority complex.

That makes me think of something else, in Spike's dream did he see multiples of Buffy around him, if so the goody good two shoes folk of Buffy did, in fact surround him. Did Spike know his dream was based on a real thing?
 
Buffy was raised to be a moral person; so she generally tries to be responsible and not abuse her powers. When she shirks her responsibility or abuses her powers- and things go wrong- she is very hard on herself, holds herself to a high standard. Basically if something goes wrong then she will ponder if it was her fault, since she is 'the Chosen One'.

Because she has the toxic tendency to mix her work life and personal life together this thought process bleeds into her relationships. So when the relationships (inevitably) go wrong she tends to blame herself. She 'made Angel a monster', she 'wasn't enough for Riley', she 'used and abused Spike so much that he got a soul (for her)'.

The end of the series has her realizing that not everything is on her and that she should try and 'spread the burden' as it were. Simultaneously she realizes that sometimes her relationships just go wrong and that's okay, she's young, she's figuring herself out, she doesn't owe anybody her emotions, etc.


Buffy can be self-righteous at times and (somewhat) self-involved (not selfish) but she doesn't really have a superiority complex, she just feels that other people cannot know what she is going through (as the slayer) and so often feels alone and isolated.

Holden's cod psychology is inciteful but comes from an evil place, not a place of truth. Vampires ultimately are sadistically demonic and want to inflict pain, not necessarily be the bearer of shining truth.
Basically Holden is an evil annoying dumbass (probably was before he was turned) and I hate him.
 
Back
Top Bottom