Buffy Summers, Agent of the First

NotASlayer

𝕮𝖍𝖔𝖈𝖔𝖑𝖆𝖙𝖊 𝕻𝖗𝖎𝖓𝖈𝖊𝖘𝖘 🍫 👸🏻
Joined
Mar 3, 2023
Messages
6,877
Location
Themiscyra
In order to explain Buffy's S7 actions, I posit she was actually working for the First. Consider:

Buffy, despite knowing that Spike was a threat, refused to do anything about it, leaving him around vulnerable girls. She instead made him more dangerous, by removing the chip, and actively tried to stop attempts to nullify the First's control over him, and only because Giles went behind her back was that control broken.

Buffy led everyone into an obvious trap, getting people killed and injured, sometimes permanently, and despite this tried to get everyone to go back which would have resulted in more deaths.

When this led to Buffy being replaced by a much more capable leader in Faith, the First, displaying a level of competence in Sunnydale it never displayed before or after, ambushed Faith with the end result that Buffy was placed back in charge.

The First let Buffy know about the Scythe, and the Potential activating spell. This did two things when used. First, it activated every Potential and turned them into a Slayer. Slayers are easier to locate than Potentials, making it that much easier for the First to hunt them down. Sure, killing them would be harder, but it had used bombs before; why not bombs and guns again? And there would be no more Potentials for some time after.

The second thing was because of this Buffy led everyone into the Hellmouth and a battle they had zero chance of winning. Without the spell, they would have had to think of something, and that something would have had a better chance of working. Only because W&H had outhought Buffy and the First was the Hellmouth destroyed, and Buffy tried to talk Spike out of blowing up.

Yes, Buffy killed Caleb, but evil bosses aren't exactly known for their compassion towards minions. Caleb had outlived his usefulness by that point.

Why would Buffy do this? Well, this is more speculative, but Willow believed Buffy was in hell. Perhaps she was right and Buffy had spent several hundred years - time doesn't move at the same rate across every dimension - being tortured by the First until she was ready to destroy the world, just like Willow would later attempt. Indeed, everything started going to hell once Buffy returned; perhaps she was the one responsible.

Why would the First be opposed to Willow destroying the world? Apocalypse creators are a jealous sort and want their apocalypse, not someone else's. Witness W&H's actions.

Discuss...

😀
 
Well, the First is an avatar for the existential concept of evil, including the evil in Buffy's heart, like the Dark Side of the Force, only lamer. So yes, it very well could be a controls your actions/obeys your commands.
 
My thanks to the Wonder Woman of Themiscyra for causing me to explain these somewhat 'silly' explanations of #1.

Did Buffy leave Spike in the company of those somewhat vulnerable girls, well yes she did. Thing is they were vulnerable at being able to beat the crap out of him.

Buffy led her people into an obvious trap where they might get killed though Buffy wanted to know about how them being killed would be regarded as being ' sometimes permanently '.

Then, was the First glad that Faith replaced Buffy, did the First think it should then attack Faith knowing that a successful raid might make them (the First) look bad ? ! um er, er tee hee.

Potentially yes it might have potentially been a good call if it wasn't, you know, potentially bad.

Could it be said that Buffy led her 20 or so girls up against the 2000 or so age old vampires with only the wizard of the magics witch as her ace in the hole before Spike Elizabeth Taylor ploy. Was Buffy praying for a good day, well yes cos all them girls had used up her supply of make up!

Yes it could be said that I discussed this but well, discussing this with myself led my around and about, as noticed by the staircase behind where Buffy told Spike her feelings.

Discussions complete.
 
In order to explain Buffy's S7 actions, I posit she was actually working for the First. Consider:

Buffy, despite knowing that Spike was a threat, refused to do anything about it, leaving him around vulnerable girls. She instead made him more dangerous, by removing the chip, and actively tried to stop attempts to nullify the First's control over him, and only because Giles went behind her back was that control broken.

Buffy led everyone into an obvious trap, getting people killed and injured, sometimes permanently, and despite this tried to get everyone to go back which would have resulted in more deaths.

When this led to Buffy being replaced by a much more capable leader in Faith, the First, displaying a level of competence in Sunnydale it never displayed before or after, ambushed Faith with the end result that Buffy was placed back in charge.

The First let Buffy know about the Scythe, and the Potential activating spell. This did two things when used. First, it activated every Potential and turned them into a Slayer. Slayers are easier to locate than Potentials, making it that much easier for the First to hunt them down. Sure, killing them would be harder, but it had used bombs before; why not bombs and guns again? And there would be no more Potentials for some time after.

The second thing was because of this Buffy led everyone into the Hellmouth and a battle they had zero chance of winning. Without the spell, they would have had to think of something, and that something would have had a better chance of working. Only because W&H had outhought Buffy and the First was the Hellmouth destroyed, and Buffy tried to talk Spike out of blowing up.

Yes, Buffy killed Caleb, but evil bosses aren't exactly known for their compassion towards minions. Caleb had outlived his usefulness by that point.

Why would Buffy do this? Well, this is more speculative, but Willow believed Buffy was in hell. Perhaps she was right and Buffy had spent several hundred years - time doesn't move at the same rate across every dimension - being tortured by the First until she was ready to destroy the world, just like Willow would later attempt. Indeed, everything started going to hell once Buffy returned; perhaps she was the one responsible.

Why would the First be opposed to Willow destroying the world? Apocalypse creators are a jealous sort and want their apocalypse, not someone else's. Witness W&H's actions.

Discuss...

😀

I mean I applaud this attempt to justify terrible writing and it would've been great writing and pretty dark if suddenly the reveal at the end that Buffy was the First and its plan succeded but no, it was simply terrible writing from people who didn't care anymore.
Hell you even left out the time Caleb literally beats Buffy unconscious but doesn't finish her off because...well reasons I guess
 
Hell you even left out the time Caleb literally beats Buffy unconscious but doesn't finish her off because...well reasons I guess
The First/Caleb is trying to end the Slayer line, but miraculously lets Buffy live. You can't help but laugh. Goes along with the bad guy revealing his plans to the good guy, making a huge speech and letting the good guy live or get the chance to escape. We see it time and time again.


@NotASlayer A compelling argument, and it's actually hard to argue against, actually 😄. No wonder she seemed off in s7!
 
The First/Caleb is trying to end the Slayer line, but miraculously lets Buffy live. You can't help but laugh. Goes along with the bad guy revealing his plans to the good guy, making a huge speech and letting the good guy live or get the chance to escape. We see it time and time again.


@NotASlayer A compelling argument, and it's actually hard to argue against, actually 😄. No wonder she seemed off in s7!
Its straight out of Austin Powers where you have to ask the Bad Guy 3 times 😂
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
Exactly!
Hell you even left out the time Caleb literally beats Buffy unconscious but doesn't finish her off because...well reasons I guess

I may have missed more. Consider, for instance, the traps for Buffy and Faith. Buffy walked into a trap so obvious all it was missing was a giant neon sign above it flashing "TRAP!!!!!!". Faith was caught by one, despite superior planning on her part, that involved the First using unknown capabilities that were literally impossible to plan for. Imagine if Buffy's trap had also used a bomb? And why didn't it?

Then there's Buffy's insistence that Spike is her best warrior, despite him being a known liability and spending the entire season being slightly less useful than a chocolate teapot, which would at least leave you with chocolate. If they're both working for the First, then that's true.

I mean I applaud this attempt to justify terrible writing and it would've been great writing and pretty dark if suddenly the reveal at the end that Buffy was the First and its plan succeded but no, it was simply terrible writing from people who didn't care anymore.
@NotASlayer A compelling argument, and it's actually hard to argue against, actually 😄. No wonder she seemed off in s7!

I know that it wasn't really what was supposed to be portrayed, but it's really quite horrific how much more sense Buffy and the First's actions make if she is on its side. Instead of it being a duel between two idiots who can't think their way out of a paper bag, it's instead a devilishly cunning plan that, if not for W&H* via Angel, nearly succeeded and, in fact, was mere seconds away from doing so even with that help. And that's the only change that needs making.

Consider what the state of things would be based on the actions of Buffy and the First alone without that interference at the end of S7.

  • The Watchers have lost their leadership, headquarters, HQ support staff, library and many field agents. That is probably not enough to wipe them out, but puts them in a position where it would take years to recover (it's a shame Angel S5 didn't genuinely explore this).
  • The Scoobies and Baby Slayers in Sunnydale would be wiped out, eliminating another group of people who know what's going on.
  • All the Potentials are now Slayers. The First was pretty much finding those who knew they were Potentials, rather than those who didn't, going by what was shown; they all had some training or connection to the Watchers. Slayers are easier to find, and even without all those who died in the first few days without knowing what was going on - because those who could tell them were all dead - finding people with superhuman abilities is easier than without. The First could hunt them down much more easily, and it would be some time before there were any new Potentials.
  • The Hellmouth would be open, probably permanently now, and the First would have its army of vampires to unleash on the world, and a town to base them, and other assets, in.

All of this, thanks to Buffy, came so very close to happening.

*It's irrelevant for this whether it was W&H, Lindsay or a combination of both.
 
I may have missed more. Consider, for instance, the traps for Buffy and Faith. Buffy walked into a trap so obvious all it was missing was a giant neon sign above it flashing "TRAP!!!!!!". Faith was caught by one, despite superior planning on her part, that involved the First using unknown capabilities that were literally impossible to plan for. Imagine if Buffy's trap had also used a bomb? And why didn't it?

what unknown capabilities for Faith's trap?

The problem I have with complaining about Buffy walking into a trap was that every season except two and six featured Buffy walking into a fight with a superior opponent on the grounds they chose. And if Spike hadn't turned on Angelus she would have done it in two also
 
Back
Top Bottom